ஆசிரியர் நியமனம் குறித்த உச்சநீதிமன்ற தீர்ப்பு. - Kalviseithi - No:1 Educational website in Tamilnadu

Sep 25, 2014

ஆசிரியர் நியமனம் குறித்த உச்சநீதிமன்ற தீர்ப்பு.

  IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION I.A.Nos.3-4/2014 IN CIVIL APPEAL Nos.9204-9205 OF 2014 (Arising out of S.L.P.(Civil) No.3860-3861/2014) The State of Tamil Nadu Rep.by its .. Appellant(s) Secretary & Ors. Versus T.S. Anbarasu & Ors. .

. Respondent(s) O R D E R Leave granted. The Teacher Recruitment Board Tamil Nadu issued an advertisement on 29th June, 2009 for filling up of two categories of posts, namely, (i) Basic Training Teachers (BTC) and (ii) Secondary Grade Teachers (SGT). It is the contention of the appellants that the advertisement reflected 6565 number of posts in both the categories whereas the stand of the respondent is that the advertisement was absolutely silent as regards the number of vacancies or the number of posts to be filled up.



It is not in dispute that the posts in question were to be filled up in accordance with the National Council for Teacher Signature Not Verified Education (Determination of Minimum Qualifications for Digitally signed by Usha Rani Bhardwaj Date: 2014.09.24 17:01:45 IST Reason: Recruitment of Teachers in Schools), Regulation, 2001 framed under the NCTE Act, 1993, by the National Council 2 for Teacher Education (NCTE). We need not advert to what the Regulation 2001 prescribed. Suffice it to say, the respondents along with many others applied for the posts in question and as put forth by the State, all the posts mentioned in the advertisement were filled up.

 There is no cavil over the fact that the respondents had filed the requisite documents and had gone through the selection procedure but they were not selected and no appointment was ever offered to them. At this juncture, it is apposite to mention that the N.C.T.E. issued a Notification on 23rd August, 2010 in exercise of power conferred by sub-section (1) of Section (23) of the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009 (for brevity "the 2009 Act"), providing certain eligibility criteria for appointment as a teacher in class I to VIII in a school referred to in Clause (n) of Section 2 of the 2009 Act.

 The conditions mentioned in the said notification relate to various aspects but in the present case we are singularly concerned with paragraph-5 of the notification. The said paragraph reads as under: "5. Teacher appointed after the date of this Notification in certain cases:- Where an appropriate Government, or local authority or a school has issued an advertisement to initiate the 3 process of appointment of teachers prior to the date of this notification, such appointments may be made in accordance with the NCTE (Determination of Minimum qualifications for Recruitment of Teachers in Schools) Regulations 2001 (as amended from time to time)." From the aforesaid paragraph it is clear as crystal that the eligibility criteria stipulated in the notification dated 23rd August, 2010 issued by the NCTE would not apply to the post that had already been advertised by the competent authority of the State.

Therefore, the advertisement issued on 29th June, 2009 remained undisturbed. In view of the aforesaid, the questions that really remain to be adjudicated are whether (i) the advertisement mentioned specific number of posts; (ii) whether the posts mentioned have already been filled up; (iii) whether the procedure of merit has been appositely followed; (iv) whether the respondents despite being more meritorious have been left out and less meritorious candidates have been appointed; and (v) whether assuming the advertisement did not mention the number of posts, the respondents still could claim a right in perpetualty to have the appointment. At this juncture, we painfully note that these aspects have not been addressed to by the High Court either by the learned Single Judge while deciding the writ petition or by the Division Bench while adjudicating 4 the writ appeal or by the subsequent Division Bench in dealing with the review.

 We restrain ourselves from adverting to the width of jurisdiction exercised by the subsequent Division Bench in exercise of power of review. As the pertinent issues have not been addressed to by the High Court we set aside all the judgments and orders of the learned Single Judge as well of the Division Bench and remit the matter to the High Court to focus on the aforesaid five aspects and decide the matter as expeditiously as possible. We may repeat at the cost of repetition that we request the High Court to dispose it of as expeditiously as possible as the matter has been pending since long.

In the result, the appeals are allowed. The orders passed by the High Court in writ appeals, writ petitions and in the review petitions are set aside and the two writ petitions are remitted to the High Court with the stipulation that the matter shall be adjudicated by a Division Bench in the backdrop of issues formulated by us so that the controversy is put to rest at the High Court level. We hereby hasten to add, if eventually the respondents succeed, they shall be offered appointment with 5 retrospective effect.

 There shall be no order as to costs. ....................J. [ DIPAK MISRA ] ...................J. [ VIKRAMAJIT SEN ] NEW DELHI, SEPTEMBER 23, 2014. 6 ITEM NO.1 COURT NO.8 SECTION XII S U P R E M E C O U R T O F I N D I A RECORD OF PROCEEDINGS I.A. Nos. 3-4/2014 in Petition(s) for Special Leave to Appeal (C) No(s). 3860-3861/2014 (Arising out of impugned final judgment and order dated 09/07/2013 in RA No. 139/2012,09/07/2013 in WA No. 1201/2012,09/07/2013 in WA No. 2121/2012 passed by the High Court Of Madras) THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU REP.

BY SEC.& ORS Petitioner(s) VERSUS T.S ANBARASU & ORS Respondent(s) (for vacating stay and office report) Date : 23/09/2014 These applications were called on for hearing today. CORAM : HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE DIPAK MISRA HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIKRAMAJIT SEN For Petitioner(s) Mr. P.P. Rao, Sr.Adv. Mr. Subramonium Prasad, AAG Mr. M. Yogesh Kanna,Adv. For Respondent(s) Mr. Nagendra Rai, Sr.Adv. Mr. A. Radhakrishnan,Adv. Mr. Neeraj Shekhar,Adv. Ms. Nalini Chidambaram, Sr.Adv. Mr. V. Balaji, Adv. Mr. Rakesh K. Sharma,Adv. UPON hearing the counsel the Court made the following O R D E R Leave granted. The appeals are allowed with no order as to costs in terms of the signed order. (USHA BHARDWAJ) (RENUKA SADANA) AR-CUM-PS (COURT MASTER) Signed order is placed on the file.

91 comments:

  1. சுப்ரிம் கோர்ட்டில் அப்பீல் பண்ணிட்டாங்களா?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. அரிது அரிது மானிடராய் பிறத்தல் அரிது
      அதனினும் அரிது ஆசிரியராய் ஆதல் அதனினும் அரிது
      பிறந்தோம் இறந்தோம் என இல்லாமல் பிறர் வாழ்த்துவது போல நல்ஆசிரியராய் திகழ எல்லாம் வல்ல முருகன் அருள் கிடைக்கட்டும்
      நல்வாழ்த்துக்களுடன் உங்களில் ஒருவன்
      நன்றி

      Delete
    2. Iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiieeeeeee. It is old news.

      Delete
    3. AIDED SCHOOL VACANT IN CHENNAI

      SCIENCE MAJOR WITH TET PASS ONLY SC CANDIDATES....

      CONTACT : 9444588966(RAJ KUMAR)

      Delete
    4. இதே தகவலை Tnteachersnews வலைதலத்தில் வெளியிட்டார்கள். அப்போது தவறான வார்த்தைகளை பயன்படுத்தி திட்டினீர்கள். ஆனால் இன்று எல்லாம் தெரிந்தவன் போல் மணியரசன் தவறான தகவலை வெளியிட்டுள்ளான். இவனை எதை கொன்டு அடிக்கலாம் என்று முடிவு செய்யுங்கள்.

      Delete
  2. Apeel panala ana news heading yen ipmi potrkanga

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. SISTER THIS IS 2010 CV CASE

      WHAT IS SAID THERE HIGH COURT SHOULD REOPEN THE CASE AND ENQUIRE IN DETAIL THAT
      HOW MANY POSTINGS DID THEY CALL FOR IN 2010,
      HOW MANY WERE FILLED,
      HOW WERE THE LEFT OUT CANDIDATES DID NOT GET JOB,

      IF THE CANDIDATES SIDE PROVED THIS THEY CAN BE APPOINTED WITHOUT WRITING TET

      IT WILL TAKE TIME AND GOVT MAY SAY THAT THEY WILL BE APPOINTED IN FUTURE VACANCIES

      SO NO PROBLEM FOR US ,

      Delete
  3. கடவுளே இது பழைய கேஸ் போட்டு குழப்பிகாதிங்க ...

    ReplyDelete
  4. Order yepo tharuvanga therija update panunga

    ReplyDelete
  5. Good news,Today approximately 11.00 a.m order issued announcement publish agum...

    Congrats 2 all.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. saravanan sir, now time is 1:10 PM, why there is no announcement still now?

      Delete
  6. Sir apo joining date pls Saravanan sir

    ReplyDelete
  7. Inaki maduraila case mudunjathan therium

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thambi pc, sir Anouncement il allam tharindhu vidum..other district teachers join pannauvadhu kurithu karuthil kolla padum..just wait 2 hours....

    ReplyDelete
  9. supreme court news enna tamil il sollunga pls...

    ReplyDelete
  10. supreme court news enna tamil il sollunga pls...

    ReplyDelete
  11. adw & others selec list eppo viduvaanga pls....

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. sir trb ku call panni kelunga i am minority language

      Delete
  12. adw & others selec list eppo viduvaanga pls....

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Adhu anaithum kan thudaippu.athaiyum thaandi podugirargal endral, miga kuraivana idangale kaanbikka padum. Azhugindra kuzhandaikku vaazhai pazham kaatugirargal, athai nambi melum naam muttalaga koodathu.

      Delete
  13. my weightage 69.58 paper 1..sc..salem dt... No job...No money...No marriage...i am very sad....any chance for me...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. For ur kindly attention plz...
      Minorities (urdu, Telagu, kanada, malayalam) & SC/ST(ADWS) TET Pass candidates.
      Coming monday we are going to TRB office & give proposal to publish our selection list.
      We prove our strength.
      If any doubt u can mail me.
      Thanveerahmed62@gmail.com

      Delete
  14. my weightage 69.58 paper 1..sc..salem dt... No job...No money...No marriage...i am very sad....any chance for me...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. senthil sir,aftr 2 weeks u,will get job, u get money, u get marry its true.... adw list, u confirm selected, ready to marry ,money,and become a gd students....

      Delete
    2. Approximately 700 post pending for welfare school .u should get job

      Delete
    3. Senthil sir feel panathinga nama teacher agurom avlotan.

      Delete
    4. Maatram varum varai Emaatrathai thavirkka mudiyadhu.

      Delete
    5. Sir kandipa ADW list varum. Ela welfare school la yum vaccant iruku

      Delete
    6. HELLO ELAN SIR WORK PANNA PORA PLACE THERINCHITINGALA .SENTHIL SIR DONT WORRY ONE WEEK LA LIST VARUM. APPADI VARALANA TRB LA POITU PORATTAM NADATHALAM. AJANTHA KUMAR ANY NEWS ABOUT ADW LIST?

      Delete
    7. sc 67.25 job kidaika chance eruka elancheran sir

      Delete
    8. Palani sir i ask deputy collector who is the head of welfare dept. He told defenetly the list will published.

      Delete
    9. palani m.sir, இன்னும் அந்த school எங்க இருக்குனு தெரியல.join order வாங்கும்போது பார்த்துகலாம்னு இருக்கேன்.. pugal sir உங்களுக்கான விடை விரைவில் trb கொடுக்கும்....

      Delete
    10. For ur kindly attention plz...
      Minorities (urdu, Telagu, kanada, malayalam) & SC/ST(ADWS) TET Pass candidates.
      Coming monday we are going to TRB office & give proposal to publish our selection list.
      We prove our strength.
      If any doubt u can mail me.
      Thanveerahmed62@gmail.com

      Delete
    11. elancheran sir adw cut off ethu varailum pogumnu ethavathu solla mudiuma sir? enaku positive 40% negative 60%nu thonuthu sir

      Delete
  15. minority language list eppo sir any body reply pls

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ungalukkana pathilai naan Mr, senthilukkum sollirukiren.

      Delete
    2. RED FIRE Nichayam Ungaluku Kadavul Karunai Purivaar KAVALAI

      Vendaam.

      Delete
  16. I am in tuty just now I check in ceo office till there is no mail rcvd once rcvd we confirm nu solranka

    ReplyDelete
  17. நண்பர்களே அனைவருக்கும் வணக்கம் நான் முன்னரே கூறியதுபோல இன்று கண்டிப்பாக நியமன ஆணை குறித்த அறிவிப்பை நம் காது குளிர கேட்கலாம் இது இறைவனனின் எழுதப்பட்ட விதி எல்லோரும் கணபதியை துதியுங்கள். Thank GOD. Kabilan are you ready.

    ReplyDelete
  18. delhi court stay kodutichu nnu solranka.idu unmaiya ?poiya?pl yaravadu konjam clear pannunka.yenakku heart attack vandidum pola.supreme couet stay tanditucha? namma job kku poka mudiyada?? aiyyaiooooooo!

    ReplyDelete
  19. Replies
    1. tariyala.yenna nadakkumoonu mansu adichikkudu....

      Delete
    2. நல்லதே நினையுங்கள்.......... நல்லதே நடக்கும் .....

      Delete
  20. appointment order eppa solluvanga, rply plz

    ReplyDelete
  21. good morning friends. madurai court news sollunga pls. order pathi edavadu sollunga

    ReplyDelete
  22. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  23. I am from virudhunagar district...I chosen vilupuram district keezupadi high school. where is this school???any hostel facilities????????? i cant get it.....Pls friends help me...My mail id brindha18592@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  24. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Nothing on tv. Ananthi wrong information. .

    ReplyDelete
  26. நல்லதே நினையுங்கள் ... நல்லதே நடக்கும் ......

    ReplyDelete
  27. Supreme court. Stayed order. உண்மையா மிக வேகமாக நாலுக்கால் பாய்சலில் பரவுகிறதே உண்மையா.அடிவயிற்றை சற்றே கலக்குகிறது.

    ReplyDelete
  28. my friend wtg 63.73, English, female,bc-(ph), 0.37 difference to job, any chance in 2nd list?

    ReplyDelete
  29. AIDED SCHOOL VACANT IN CHENNAI

    SCIENCE MAJOR WITH TET PASS ONLY SC CANDIDATES....

    CONTACT : 9444588966(RAJ KUMAR)

    ReplyDelete
  30. May2010 சான்றிதழ் சரிபார்ப்பில் கலந்து கொண்ட 94 பேர் சென்னை உயர் நீதிமன்றத்தில் வழக்கு தொடுத்தனர் .இதை விசாரித்த அமர்வு நீதிமன்றம் 23.08.2010 முன்பு சான்றிதழ் சரிபார்ப்பில் கலந்து கொண்டவர்கள் TET தேர்வு எழுத வேண்டாம் என்றும் வேலை வாய்ப்பில் முன்னுரிமை வழங்க வேண்டும் என்றும் தீர்ப்பு வழங்கியுள்ளது .இதை எதிர்த்து அரசு உச்ச நீதிமன்றத்தில் மேல்முறையிடு செய்தது .இதை விசாரித்த உச்சநீதி மன்றம்
    உயர் நீதிமன்றம் வழங்கிய தீர்ப்பு சரி என்றும் ஆனால் எவ்வளவு பணி இடங்கள் என்று அறிவிக்கபடவில்லை.23.8.2010 முன்பு நிலுவையில் உள்ள அரசானைகள் எவ்வளவு பணிஇடங்கள் நிரப்ப வேண்டும் என்று உயர் நீதி மன்றத்தில் தாக்கல் செய்ய வேண்டும் என்று உத்தரவு பிறப்பிக்கப்பட்டுள்ளது. உச்ச நீதிமன்றம் கேட்ட 5 கேள்விகள் உயர் நீதிமன்றத்தில் தாக்கல் செய்யவேண்டும். அந்த கேள்விகள்
    the advertisement issued on 29th June, 2009 remained undisturbed. In view of the aforesaid, the questions that really remain to be adjudicated are whether (i) the advertisement mentioned specific number of posts; (ii) whether the posts mentioned have already been filled up; (iii) whether the procedure of merit has been appositely followed; (iv) whether the respondents despite being more meritorious have been left out and less meritorious candidates have been appointed; and (v) whether assuming the advertisement did not mention the number of posts, the respondents still could claim a right in perpetualty to have the appointment.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. alex sir tell me about 2nd list and both pg and bt selected candidates

      Delete
    2. Ramesh sir,pls let me know whether there is possibility to get job for those who attended CV in 2010. iam also eagerly waiting.when will we know about it.

      Delete
  31. vijay chennai sir plz update present news...... we are eagerly waiting for your valuable coment........................

    ReplyDelete
  32. Sir Evvalavo parthuttom ithayum paarthudalam....suppose case pottu anga Case angayum dismiss aana case pottavanga, 13000 perkkum kattayam nasta edu tharanum...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. YES YOU are 100% CORRECT BESTSIVA Sir ENNA NADAKANUMNU

      Iruko athu nadakum ithanaal enna innum oru 20 naatkal thaamatham

      aagapothu aagatum paarthukalaam.

      Delete
  33. ithu ena news ethum puriyavillai enkaluku job kudupinkala matinkala atha solunka plz

    ReplyDelete
  34. who are lost job in paper2 with in 0.0 something please call 8220803143

    ReplyDelete
  35. wat is going on..pls any one share ,,,

    ReplyDelete
  36. VELAI VAAIPU 0.0 ALAVIL ARUGE ILANDHAVARGALUKKU ORU VAIIPU ULLADHU ONDRU KUUDUVOM VETRI URUDHI PLEASE CALL 8220803143

    ReplyDelete
  37. WHO ARE LOST JOB WITH IN O.O LEVEL PLEASE CALL 8220803143,9626765676

    ReplyDelete
  38. Adw vaccant expected cut off 68.62
    Today evening after 6pm will be announced.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. epadi solringa paper1 and paper 2 ah.please reply

      Delete
    2. Is there any possibility for PG second list?????? AAs sir vijay Kumar Chennai sir sri sir Chandra Kumar sir pls reply me.....

      Delete
  39. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  40. kalviseithi adminukku oru vendukol.......confirm illama.....kidaikkum thagavalai ellaam publish pannaatheenga.....Theva illama ellorayum neengalum kayapaduthaatheenga....ithu enna innaikku vantha newsa....?

    ReplyDelete
  41. chandra kumar mayan sir, pls neenga solvathu unmaya...today after 6 pm adw list ethir pakkalama? pls give ur mobile number..or..call me.8508609141...

    ReplyDelete
  42. chandra kumar mayan sir, pls neenga solvathu unmaya...today after 6 pm adw list ethir pakkalama? pls give ur mobile number..or..call me.8508609141...

    ReplyDelete
  43. chandra kumar sir unga wtg mark evvlo...neenga entha district..pap1 or pap 2 ah...

    ReplyDelete
  44. Kadul illa aparm nethi enga irruku.today money make something

    ReplyDelete
  45. tntet 2013 is going to climax...but now twist mela twist nadakkuthu...end nalla mudiva irukka vendum..oh god beautiful!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  46. tntet 2013 is going to climax...but now twist mela twist nadakkuthu...end nalla mudiva irukka vendum..oh god beautiful!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  47. all the best for all new pg teachers because pg-trining ..........

    ReplyDelete

கல்விச்செய்தி நண்பர்களே..
நீங்கள் ஒவ்வொருவரும் கல்விச்செய்தியின் அங்கமே..
வாசகர்களின் கருத்து சுதந்திரத்தை வரவேற்கும் இந்தப்பகுதியை ஆரோக்கியமாக பயன்படுத்திக் கொள்ள அன்புடன் வேண்டுகிறோம்.

குறிப்பு:
1. இங்கு பதிவாகும் கருத்துக்கள் வாசகர்களின் சொந்த கருத்துக்களே. கல்விச்செய்தி இதற்கு எவ்வகையிலும் பொறுப்பல்ல.
2. கருத்தை நிராகரிக்கவோ, குறைக்கவோ, தணிக்கை செய்யவோ கல்விச்செய்தி குழுவுக்கு முழு உரிமை உண்டு.
3. தனிமனித தாக்குதல்கள், நாகரிகமற்ற வார்த்தைகள், படைப்புக்கு பொருத்தமில்லாத கருத்துகள் நீக்கப்படும்.
4. தங்களின் பெயர் மற்றும் சரியான மின்னஞ்சல் முகவரியை பயன்படுத்தி கருத்தை பதிவிட அன்புடன் வேண்டுகிறோம்.
-அன்புடன் கல்விச்செய்தி