ஆசிரியர் தேர்வு வாரியம் நடத்திய முதுநிலை பட்டதாரி ஆசிரியர் பணித்தேர்வில் கேட்கப்பட்ட தவறான கேள்விகளுக்கு உரிய மதிப் பெண்ணை ஐகோர்ட் கிளை நேரடியாக
வழங்கியது. மதுரைகருப்பாயூரணியை சேர்ந்த ராமச்சந்திரன்,ஐகோர்ட் கிளையில் தாக்கல் செய்த மனு: நான் எம்.காம்,எம்.பில்,பிஎட் முடித்துள்ளேன். தமிழகத்தில் கடந்த ஜூலை 21ல் நடந்த முதுநிலை பட்டதாரி ஆசிரியர் (வணிகவியல்) பணித்தேர்வில் கலந்துகொண்டேன்.இந்த தேர்வு முடிவின் தற்காலிக விடை சுருக்கத்திலும்,இறுதி விடை சுருக்கத்திலும் குறிப்பிடப்பட்டிருந்த பதில்கள் வேறுவேறாக இருந்தன. நான்ஐந்து கேள்விகளுக்கு சரியாக பதில் அளித்திருந்தேன். அதற்கு மதிப்பெண் வழங்கவில்லை. நான் பிற்படுத்தப்பட்டோர் வகுப்பை சேர்ந்தவன் என்பதால் கட்,ஆப் மதிப்பெண் 107 என நிர்ணயிக்கப்பட்டிருந்தது. ஆனால் நான் 103 மதிப்பெண் பெற்றேன். எனவே,தவறான கேள்விகளுக்கு மதிப்பெண் வழங்கி,என்னை ஆசிரியர் பணிக்கு தேர்வு செய்ய உத்தரவிட வேண்டும். இவ்வாறு மனுவில் கூறப்பட்டிருந்தது.இவரைப்போன்று மேலும் பலர் முழு மதிப்பெண் வழங்கக்கோரி மனுத்தாக்கல் செய்திருந்தனர். இந்த மனுக்களை நீதிபதி எஸ்.நாகமுத்து விசாரித்தார். இந்தமனுக்கள் ஏற்கனவே விசாரணைக்கு வந்தபோது,நிபுணர் குழு ஒன்றை அமைத்து நீதிபதி உத்தரவிட்டார்.இந்தநிலையில்,இந்த வழக்கு நீதிபதி நாகமுத்து முன் மீண்டும் விசாரணைக்கு வந்தது. அப்போது,நிபுணர்கள் குழு நேரில் ஆஜராகி,ஆய்வு அறிக்கையை சமர்ப்பித்தனர். அந்த அறிக்கையை,பாடப்புத்தகங்களுடன் ஒப்பிட்டுப் பார்த்து,தவறான கேள்வி மற்றும் பதில்களுக்கு உரிய மதிப்பெண்களை நீதிபதி நேரடியாக வழங்கினார். அந்த மதிப்பெண் அடிப்படையில் மனுதாரர்களை ஆசிரியர் பணிக்கு பரிசீலிக்க வேண்டும் என்று ஆசிரியர் தேர்வு வாரியத்திற்கு நீதிபதி உத்தரவிட்டார்.
Case pottavarukku mattum than marka, illai ellorukkum revalue seithu mark poduvangala? answer thappu yendral athu anaivarukkum thane poruthum.
ReplyDeletesome botany friends also going to file case for wrong key issue. I think it is better all subjects key should be verified by the court. all people can get justice.including education and women quota problem.
ReplyDeleteSir plz rep sir
Deleteout of 5 petitioners plea, only one petitioner got grace mark...that too 1 mark only....4 petitions got rejected...trb this time publish 100% correct answer...please file case...u know it...
ReplyDeleteSIR YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT BOTANY OR COMMERCE SUBJECT? LET US KNOW SIR
DeleteWhat r the questions?
Deleteodunga..odunga..adhu nammalae nokki than vanthuttu irukku....
Deletetwo more cases are pending. court la proof panniya pirakum eppadi 100% correct nu solrenga nu theriyala
ReplyDeleteDear Commerce nanba, pls tell which question and answers are re valued by the court and how many marks are awarded. this is useful for all commerce candidates.
ReplyDeletesir, in commerce which questions are verified by the court ?
ReplyDeleteAny botany candidates going to file case for wrong key pls give ur contact number, i will join with u , i too have 2 evidences with textbook and foreing author evidence, give ur num i wil contact with u,
ReplyDeletekilampitaangayaa...kilampitaangayaa
DeleteBotany candidates plz tell what ques
ReplyDeleteif court revalued the questions in commerce, the same answer is applicable to all candidates, so TRB should revise the key according to court order and also publish the latest cut off marks, because somebody may get marks for wrong answer by TRB, so their marks will also change. So the Court should order TRB to re value the answer sheet for all commerce candidate. ONE PERSON GETTING MARKS BY COURT IS INJUSTICE TO NATION.
ReplyDeletenaanun jailuku poren ,nanum periya rowdi than,ennaiyum aethittu ponga..
DeleteWhat is injustice...if U want marks ,U file the case...justice doesnot order trb to include that person in rank list...he just asked to consider him.....hereafter no one delay the trb process
ReplyDeleteevery body could not file case, it will take more time for court as well as remote area candidates. so one order should prevail to all this is justice. see all the cases one order by court shall lead all the cases by court. i understand about your afraid , i think u would have selected thats why u r comment like this.
ReplyDeleteNote one thing friend , court just ask trb to consider this candidate that is all at the same time trb also will show their evidence for their answer in court then only this candidature problem will be solved.The reason why the court is giving order only to that person means because he is the only approached court for his justice.
Deletewhat you are talking? my god.....
DeleteIf justice found errors in answer keys,he ordered trb to revaluate...last year too he ordered like that...but this time he ordered trb to consider that person only....trb submitted detailed report on final keys... Justice accepted it....
ReplyDeleteyes last year every thing was changed, because trb didnot pulish final answer key but this year all answers carefully checked and they must be having evidence too....
Deletesee the case in detail in NEW INDIAN EXPRESS NEWS PAPER on 07.11.2013 Chennai edition on page no:4
DeleteNo last year also TRb published final answer key, now i have the copy of final key
DeleteEverybody has right to go court for justice but before going, be sure with evidence, for example most of the commerce candidates think that answer for 1/6 th scheme is 2007-2008, even in tentative, trb gave this answer only, because in many text books given this but actually that is 2006-2007 that is why in final key previous one is changed, trb surely having evidence .this is one example... like this many.
DeleteSee, in commerce the question is Euro Dollar is? Here TRb answer is dollar used in European countries, but the Correct answer is Option A. Availability of Dollar outside USA. hence this is one example for wrong answer given by TRB. anybody can chech this answer by typing this question in Google, the Wikipedia answer clearly says that Euro Dollar is availability of Dollar out side USA.
Deletesee the case in detail in NEW INDIAN EXPRESS NEWS PAPER on 07.11.2013 Chennai edition on page no:4
ReplyDeleteActing on the recommendations of subject experts, the Madras High Court (Madurai Bench) has awarded marks for erroneous questions to candidates of an examination conducted by the Teachers Recruitment Board (TRB) for the post of Postgraduate Assistants on July 21 this year.
ReplyDeleteJustice S Nagamuthu, before whom writ petitions were filed seeking to award marks for erroneous questions, wrong key answers, incomplete questions and typography errors, sought the help of experts in the subject and disposed of the petitions.
A team comprising associate professors from Presidency College and Nandanam Government Arts College in Chennai had recommended awarding of marks for certain questions in the subjects of Science, Mathematics, Commerce and History. After obtaining the expert opinion, the judge cross-checked the facts with textbooks and awarded marks for erroneous questions. The judge and the experts found that for certain questions none of the options given as answers by the TRB were right. The TRB also agreed with the judge’s decision to grant marks for the said questions. The TRB also submitted that they were ready to delete questions which were incomplete or failed to convey the right meaning.
Justice Nagamuthu also rejected some claims of the petitioner for marks, where he found that the key answers were actually right contrary to the contention of the petitioners.
Conti
Pg appointment by next week.confirm news.
ReplyDeletesir ho told or from where u got this cofirm news
DeleteIs it really true news? I am really waiting fir your reply.please reply me sir/ madam.
Deletecommerce il thavarana kelvigaluku mattuma illa key lyum thappu irukka
ReplyDeleteconfirm news from whom sir?
ReplyDeleteSee, in commerce the question is Euro Dollar is? Here TRb answer is dollar used in European countries, but the Correct answer is Option A. Availability of Dollar outside USA. hence this is one example for wrong answer given by TRB. anybody can chech this answer by typing this question in Google, the Wikipedia answer clearly says that Euro Dollar is availability of Dollar out side USA.
ReplyDeleteEuropean countries also out side the USA only, except European countries it can be said only US dollor but not Euro dollar.
DeleteThe term was originally coined for U.S. dollars in European banks. u check Wikipedia u can find this term.now it is expanded only to Tokyo and Beijing only not all over world.u have seen only first line but go through original definition sir.
Deleteஉஷ்ஷ்ஷ்...இப்பவே கண்ண கட்டுதே..
Deleteஎதையுமே ப்ளேன் பண்ணி பண்ணனும்..எவ்வளவு நேரம்தான் வலிக்காத மாதிரியே நடிக்கிறது... / வேணாம்... வலிக்குது... அழுதுடுவன்..
Aaah oonnaa ani aniyaa kodi pudichi vandhudaraanga....
ReplyDeletesee last line in judgment " andtha mathipen adipadayil manuthararargalai aasiriyar panikku parisilikkumaru utharavittar" so not only one person or only commerce so we do not know whether commerce candidate also included in that "manuthararagal"(petitioner)
ReplyDeleteloosu pasanga, exam result vantha 5 days enna senchirunthanga evanga,ippa than kandupidika mudichandha,avanavan velai vetti vittitu appointmentku wait pannitu iruntha,ani aniyaa kilampidaranga
ReplyDeleteமத்தவங்க வாழ்க்கையை கெடுத்து கேஸ் போட்டு போஸ்டிங் வாங்கி அந்த பாவத்தை பண்ணுங்க!
ReplyDeleteAnybody have court order for last year 2012 pg trb to get job for equivalent subjects who have GO for the subjects after exam . still not get it . conduct 8148622030
ReplyDeletethis court order regarding what sir?
Deleteso according to the judgement some questions may be deleted, some answers may be changed so court kku pona than ethavadhu nadakkudhu.
ReplyDeleteஇந்த மாதிரி கேஸ் போட்டு உங்களுக்கு சாதகமா தீர்ப்பு வந்தா உடனே உங்களுக்கு டி.ஆர்.பி அப்பாயிண்ட்மன்ட் கொடுத்துருவாங்க
ReplyDeleteஒரு வருஷம் ஆனாலும் உங்களுக்கு போஸ்டிங் கொடுக்கப்போறது இல்ல
nothing will happen if they put 100 cases also....
Deleteidhu enna punch dialogue aaa adikkadi solrenga
Deleteappo indian express news kku enna artham
Deletekonjam mark potirkkanga athu enna subjectunu theryathu avangaloda markin adipadiyil consider pannunganu than judgement koduthrikkar velaikku eduthukkangnu sollala
Deletewhat are the subjects? what are the questions? and how many questions? iam very eager to know that.
ReplyDeleteசிங்கம் களம் இறங்கியது
Deletedear commerce graduates tax- one by six scheme abolished 2007-08... only correct answer. some of them told many many books.. i do not know how they produce .. only one book says 2006-07 and net also financial bill proposed on feb 28,2006 ay... In 2006-07 ay we calculate tax for 2005-06 so we can not abolish this in 2006-2007. effect comes from 2007-08... i think many of them want to read basic about tax.. we have referred five books the answer is 2007-2008 only... hello friends tentative answer also experts recommened final answer key also experts... where is mistake... authors book evevrythink wrong .. in syllabus not mentioned which author book we want to refer... experts follow one book we follow one book.. both books are used by all over india... so first book should be analysed by _????????????????????????????????????????????????/
ReplyDeleteSir, Feb 2006 abolished means for 2006-2007 ay only. that is ,while filing the return before 31 july 2007 not necessary to follow 1/6 scheme. because Feb budget for 1st april 2006 to 31 st march 2007 only. quite simple to understand . More over for compettiive exams how they can prescribe books. Authors should update time to time or at least they have to give additional pages as appendix but they are not doing.only Income tax written by Hariharan given correctly.
Deletefor tax, if we have doubt means better to get information from particular tax dept website.
Deletepg asst final list varuma marupadiyum case ah?
ReplyDeletein pg asst cv list women quota is fully omitted.any women candidate loose the chance by 1 or 2 marks approach a lawyer, verify it then file a case. somebody said everything is perfect don't mind it.
ReplyDeletesee notification in some communal tern there is no vacancy for women or you count subject wise with notification dont misguide the people pls
ReplyDeletetheriyalaaipa Shivaji tone a ninaichukonga sir madam
ReplyDeletePG final key will be modified and will be released soon.................
ReplyDeletein which subject ? how many questions?
Delete/
Hello Murthy sir sry my mobile jammd thats why I reply now Im a sec grd teacher now so I prefer pg When can we expect our appoinmnt any idea
ReplyDeleteFinal answer key in commerce is correct.if they revise the key once again,I will file case against it.
ReplyDeletesir you dont worry, did u see dinakaran newspaper today? what director told about TET, final key cannt be changed if there is problem let us see.. this is the answer from vibu nair. How these people are telling final key will be modified? just to aduthavanga vayitha erikkrathukku mattum than. so you should not worry. commercile ellame correct than.
Deleteeven for commerce here somebody mentioned about wrong answer but i have given correct reply they cannot deny. in tentative key i found some wrong answer i submitted correct answers with evidence. first we should know one thing,, simply they wont change tentative key before changing the given answer they will check thoroughly and will have full evidence without that they will not change.
DeleteCase ptavangalukku consider panna solli sollunvanga courtil appram trb tha mudivu pannum. key ellam mathamattanga appram neenga case potta marubadiyim mathiitu irupanagala sir? avangalukku vere velaye illaya
Deletedear Ram raj what is your contact number?
Deletevery good . any way varappora final key I court than final pannum
ReplyDeletewhy trb is doing like this? controversiala edukku question paper set panranga clear cutta edukku edudhan ans endru q paper set panna muduyadha?according to the court for some questions all the four choices are wrong some questions are not convey the correct meaning some questions have more than one answer and also printing mistake for some questions we cannot find the answer from anywhere idula reservation women quota, tamil medium quota weitage problem high court should verifiy all questions in all subjects in education for some questions we cannot find answer from anywhere
ReplyDeleteall questions cannot be asked directly few questions will be asked to check our presence of mind. we have to use our IQ. As a teacher u must be knowing sir. mine also i could not get marks for many education question. what to do our fate
Delete